What are the important Differences and Similarities between FERA and FEMA

FERA

FERA stands for the Foreign Exchange Regulation Act. It was an Indian law that regulated foreign exchange transactions, currency holdings, and certain aspects of foreign trade and payments in India. FERA was enacted in 1973 as a response to the economic challenges faced by India, including foreign exchange shortages and balance of payments issues. The primary goal of FERA was to conserve foreign exchange and ensure its proper utilization for essential imports and economic development.

FERA was replaced by the Foreign Exchange Management Act (FEMA) in 1999, which introduced a more liberalized and market-oriented approach to foreign exchange regulations. FEMA aimed to simplify foreign exchange transactions, encourage foreign investment, and align India’s foreign exchange policies with global economic trends. Unlike FERA, which focused on control and restrictions, FEMA emphasized promoting trade and investment while maintaining safeguards against money laundering and illegal transactions.

Features of FERA:

1. Foreign Exchange Control: FERA granted the Indian government extensive control over foreign exchange transactions, including the purchase, sale, holding, and utilization of foreign currency.
2. Regulation of Transactions: FERA required individuals and businesses to obtain government approval for various foreign exchange transactions, including overseas investments, remittances, and payments.
3. Resident and Non-Resident Classification: FERA defined residents and non-residents based on the duration of stay abroad, and different rules applied to their foreign exchange dealings.
4. Authorized Dealers: Foreign exchange transactions were conducted through authorized dealers, who were licensed financial institutions designated by the government.
5. Penalties and Enforcement: FERA imposed strict penalties for violations, including fines and imprisonment, to discourage illegal foreign exchange transactions.
6. Control of Foreign Assets: FERA allowed the government to control and regulate the ownership and transfer of foreign assets by Indian citizens and entities.

FEMA

FEMA stands for the Foreign Exchange Management Act. It is an Indian law enacted in 1999 to regulate foreign exchange transactions, external trade, payments, and foreign investment in India. FEMA replaced the earlier Foreign Exchange Regulation Act (FERA) with a more modern and market-oriented framework that aligns with the changing economic landscape and India’s integration into the global economy.

Features of FEMA:

1. Liberalization: FEMA introduced a more liberalized approach to foreign exchange regulations, emphasizing simplification, transparency, and facilitation of foreign exchange transactions.
2. Current Account Transactions: FEMA categorizes foreign exchange transactions into current account and capital account transactions. Current account transactions, which include trade in goods and services, do not require specific permission and are mostly free from restrictions.
3. Capital Account Transactions: Capital account transactions, such as foreign investments and transfers of capital, are subject to specific regulations, approvals, and reporting requirements.
4. Authorized Persons: FEMA designates authorized persons, including banks and financial institutions, to handle foreign exchange transactions on behalf of individuals and businesses.
5. Foreign Investment: FEMA sets guidelines for foreign investment in India, including foreign direct investment (FDI) and foreign portfolio investment (FPI). It prescribes sectors where FDI is allowed, the maximum permissible limits, and reporting requirements.
6. Foreign Exchange Management: FEMA focuses on effective management of foreign exchange rather than strict control. It aims to promote external trade, investment, and economic growth while maintaining safeguards against money laundering, illegal transactions, and capital flight.
7. Enforcement and Penalties: Like FERA, FEMA has provisions for penalties and enforcement against violations. It ensures compliance with foreign exchange regulations through inspections, investigations, and adjudication.
8. Foreign Exchange Violations: FEMA classifies foreign exchange violations into technical and substantive violations, each with its own penalty structure. Penalties can include fines, confiscation of assets, and even imprisonment in some cases.
9. Reserve Bank of India (RBI): The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) plays a key role in administering and implementing FEMA. It issues regulations, approvals, and guidelines to ensure compliance with foreign exchange rules.

To whom it is applicable?

1. Indian Residents: FEMA is applicable to individuals, companies, partnerships, trusts, and any other entities that are considered residents of India. A resident is defined based on the duration of stay in India during a financial year.
2. Non-Resident Indians (NRIs): NRIs, who are Indian citizens living abroad, are subject to certain provisions of FEMA when it comes to their Indian assets, investments, and transactions.
3. Foreign Nationals: Foreign nationals residing in India and conducting business or investment activities that involve foreign exchange transactions are also subject to FEMA regulations.
4. Business Entities: Indian companies, partnerships, sole proprietorships, and other business entities engaged in international trade, foreign investments, and transactions involving foreign exchange are subject to FEMA.
5. Financial Institutions: Authorized banks, financial institutions, and entities designated by the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) to handle foreign exchange transactions on behalf of residents and non-residents are also subject to FEMA.
6. Foreign Investors: Foreign investors, including foreign direct investors (FDIs) and foreign portfolio investors (FPIs), are subject to FEMA regulations when making investments in India.
7. Importers and Exporters: Businesses involved in international trade, importing and exporting goods and services, are subject to FEMA regulations for payment and receipt of foreign exchange.
8. Foreign Companies: Foreign companies operating in India or seeking to invest in Indian businesses are subject to FEMA regulations regarding investment, repatriation, and other foreign exchange transactions.
9. Non-Governmental Organizations (NGOs): NGOs receiving foreign funding are subject to FEMA regulations to ensure proper utilization and reporting of foreign contributions.
10. Real Estate Transactions: Individuals and entities involved in foreign investment in real estate, including property purchase, are subject to FEMA regulations.
11. Foreign Borrowings: Entities raising foreign loans or issuing foreign currency bonds are subject to FEMA regulations governing external commercial borrowings (ECBs).
12. Foreign Exchange Earnings: Entities earning foreign exchange through various activities, such as export of goods and services, are subject to FEMA regulations for repatriation and utilization of earnings.

Adjudication and appeal under FEMA

Adjudication:

1. Adjudicating Authority: The Adjudicating Authority, appointed by the Central Government, is responsible for adjudicating cases of alleged violations of FEMA provisions.
2. Initiation of Proceedings: The Adjudicating Authority can initiate proceedings against any person or entity suspected of violating FEMA regulations. This can be based on information received or suo motu (on its own motion).
3. Notice to the Accused: The Adjudicating Authority issues a show-cause notice to the accused, outlining the alleged violation and seeking their response within a specified period.
4. Reply and Hearing: The accused has the opportunity to submit a written reply to the show-cause notice, presenting their defense. They may also request a personal hearing before the Adjudicating Authority.
5. Decision: After considering the response and conducting a hearing (if requested), the Adjudicating Authority issues an order determining whether a violation has occurred. If a violation is found, penalties and fines are imposed as per FEMA provisions.
6. Penalties: The penalties imposed by the Adjudicating Authority can include monetary fines, confiscation of foreign exchange, assets, or instruments involved in the violation, and penalties for continuing violations.

Appeal:

1. Appellate Tribunal: If a person or entity is aggrieved by the decision of the Adjudicating Authority, they have the right to appeal to the Appellate Tribunal established under FEMA.
2. Filing an Appeal: The aggrieved party must file an appeal with the Appellate Tribunal within 45 days from the date of receipt of the Adjudicating Authority’s order.
3. Review of Order: The Appellate Tribunal reviews the facts, evidence, and legal aspects of the case to determine whether the Adjudicating Authority’s decision was correct.
4. Decision: Based on its review, the Appellate Tribunal may uphold, modify, or reverse the Adjudicating Authority’s order. It can also remand the matter back to the Adjudicating Authority for further consideration.
5. Judicial Review: If dissatisfied with the Appellate Tribunal’s decision, parties can seek a judicial review by the High Court.
6. Finality: The decision of the Appellate Tribunal (or the High Court, if applicable) is final and binding on the parties.

Advantages of the Foreign Exchange Management Act (FEMA):

1. Modernized Regulatory Framework: FEMA replaced the more restrictive Foreign Exchange Regulation Act (FERA) with a more modern and market-oriented approach to foreign exchange regulation.
2. Liberalization: FEMA introduced greater flexibility and liberalization in foreign exchange transactions, making it easier for individuals and businesses to engage in cross-border trade and investments.
3. Transparency and Simplicity: FEMA simplified foreign exchange regulations, making them more transparent and accessible to individuals and entities engaged in foreign exchange transactions.
4. Facilitation of Trade: FEMA streamlines procedures for current account transactions related to trade in goods and services, reducing bureaucratic hurdles for importers and exporters.
5. Foreign Investment Promotion: FEMA encourages foreign direct investment (FDI) and foreign portfolio investment (FPI) by providing a clear framework for foreign investors to invest in India.
6. Reserve Bank of India (RBI) Oversight: FEMA empowers the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) to regulate and supervise foreign exchange transactions, ensuring a robust regulatory mechanism.
7. Enhanced Reporting: FEMA requires entities to report foreign exchange transactions, investments, and holdings to the RBI, improving transparency and data collection.
8. Repatriation of Earnings: FEMA facilitates the repatriation of earnings from foreign investments, providing more flexibility to investors.
9. Safeguard Against Money Laundering: FEMA includes provisions to prevent money laundering and illegal transactions, aligning with international standards.

Disadvantages of the Foreign Exchange Management Act (FEMA):

1. Complexity for Some Transactions: While FEMA aims to simplify regulations, certain capital account transactions, especially those involving foreign investments, can still involve complexities and regulatory requirements.
2. Bureaucratic Processes: In some cases, individuals and entities may need to navigate bureaucratic processes for approvals and reporting, which can be time-consuming.
3. Potential for Misinterpretation: The evolving nature of global markets and financial instruments could lead to misinterpretation of certain provisions, requiring ongoing regulatory clarification.
4. Penalties and Enforcement: Violations of FEMA regulations can lead to penalties, fines, and legal consequences, potentially impacting businesses and individuals.
5. Currency Risk: Currency fluctuations can impact foreign exchange transactions and investments, affecting returns for investors.
6. Selective Regulation: While FEMA has liberalized regulations, certain sectors and transactions may still be subject to stricter controls and approval processes.
7. Foreign Exchange Exposure: Businesses engaging in international trade and foreign investments remain exposed to foreign exchange rate fluctuations and associated risks.
8. Compliance Burden: Businesses need to ensure compliance with FEMA reporting requirements, which may involve additional administrative efforts.

Important Differences between FERA and FEMA

Advisory Note: Article shared based on knowledge available on internet and for the Knowledge purpose only. Please contact Professional/Advisor/Doctor for treatment/Consultation.

Articles on intactone.com are general information, and are not intended to substitute for Professional Advice. The information is “AS IS”, “WITH ALL FAULTS”. User assumes all risk of Use, Damage, or Injury. You agree that we have no liability for any damages.