by The term lien refers to the right to retain possession of another person’s property until a debt or obligation is fulfilled. It is a legal claim that enables a person (usually a creditor or bailee) to hold goods lawfully in their possession until payment or compensation is made.
Definition (Implied under Indian Contract Act)
Although the Indian Contract Act does not explicitly define lien in one section, it is implied in Sections 170 and 171, which deal with bailee’s particular and general lien.
Lien is the right of a person in possession of goods to retain them until dues related to those goods are paid.
Features of Contract of Lien:
- Right to Retain Possession
The most fundamental feature of a lien is the right to retain possession of goods until a debt or obligation is fulfilled. The person who has lawful possession of someone else’s goods, such as a bailee, may refuse to return those goods until the dues are cleared. This right acts as a security for payment or service rendered. However, it does not confer ownership or a right to use the goods—only to hold them until settlement.
- Does Not Transfer Ownership
A lien provides only the right to possession, not ownership of the goods. The creditor or bailee does not become the owner of the retained goods. The debtor or bailor remains the lawful owner throughout. The lienholder simply has the legal right to retain the goods until payment is made. This feature is important in distinguishing lien from a pledge or sale, where rights are greater or ownership can be transferred under specific conditions.
- Arises from Law or Contract
A lien can arise either by operation of law or through express/implied contract. In some cases, statutes like the Indian Contract Act (Sections 170 and 171) provide for lien rights. In other instances, lien may be created by a specific agreement between parties. For example, warehouse service agreements may include lien clauses. This dual nature (statutory and contractual) gives lien both a legal and practical foundation in commercial and legal dealings.
- Conditional Upon Debt or Obligation
The lien is not absolute; it arises only when an obligation remains unpaid. The person in possession must have provided a service, loan, or facility for which compensation is due. If there is no due amount or the claim is settled, the lien becomes void, and the goods must be returned. This feature ensures that lien is conditional and not arbitrary, protecting the rights of both the lienholder and the actual owner of the goods.
- Passive Right – No Right to Sell
In a general lien, the holder can retain goods but has no right to sell them, unless this power is expressly granted by contract or law. This makes lien a passive right, unlike a pledge, where the pawnee can sell the goods on default. The lienholder must wait for the debtor to settle the dues and cannot actively convert the goods into money without appropriate legal provision. This maintains balance and prevents misuse of possession.
- Ends Upon Debt Settlement
The lien automatically ceases when the underlying debt or obligation is satisfied. Once payment is made or the service charge is settled, the lienholder is legally obligated to return the goods to the owner. Holding the goods beyond this point would be considered unlawful detention or even conversion. This feature emphasizes that lien is temporary in nature and functions only as a security mechanism until the debtor fulfills their obligation.
- Applicable Only on Lawful Possession
The person exercising the lien must have lawful and continuous possession of the goods. If the possession is acquired unlawfully (e.g., through theft or fraud), lien cannot be claimed. Also, if the goods are voluntarily returned or possession is lost, the right of lien is extinguished. This feature ensures that lien is exercised in good faith and within legal boundaries. It protects owners from unjustified withholding of property under false lien claims.
- Two Types – Particular and General Lien
A lien is categorized into Particular Lien and General Lien. A particular lien is specific to the goods involved in a service (e.g., tailor retaining clothes for unpaid stitching). A general lien allows certain professionals (e.g., bankers, attorneys) to retain any goods for general dues. This classification helps determine who can exercise lien, under what circumstances, and on what kind of goods, making it a flexible yet regulated legal right in commercial practice.
Essentials for Valid Lien:
- Lawful Possession of Goods
The first essential of a valid lien is that the lienholder must have lawful possession of the goods. The possession should not be illegal, accidental, or under duress. For example, if a mechanic has a vehicle for repair with the owner’s consent, they have lawful possession. However, if the goods are stolen or acquired by fraud, no lien can be claimed. Lawful possession ensures the lien arises from a genuine legal or contractual relationship.
- No Transfer of Ownership
In a valid lien, ownership remains with the original owner, not with the person holding the goods. The lienholder may retain the goods, but they have no legal title to sell, modify, or claim ownership unless the law or agreement provides otherwise. This feature distinguishes lien from a pledge or mortgage. The limited right to possess but not own ensures that the lienholder is acting as a custodian, not as a buyer or seller.
- Debt Must Be Due and Payable
Valid lien arises only when a payment or obligation is due and unpaid. If the debt is not yet due, or if the obligation has been fulfilled, the lien is invalid. The person holding the lien must show that a legally enforceable claim exists. For example, a tailor can retain a suit until the stitching charges are paid. Without an outstanding debt, retaining goods would amount to unlawful detention.
- Possession Must Be Continuous
For a lien to be valid, the possession of the goods by the lienholder must be uninterrupted and continuous. If the goods are voluntarily returned or the possession is lost, the lien is terminated. The lienholder cannot reclaim lien rights once the goods are returned. This continuous control ensures that the lien is exercised as a shield, not as a sword. The lien is lost the moment voluntary surrender occurs.
- No Agreement to Waive Lien
If there is an explicit or implied agreement to waive the lien, the lienholder loses the right to retain the goods. For example, if a service contract includes a clause stating that goods will be returned regardless of payment, lien cannot be claimed. Waiver may be express (in writing) or implied by conduct, such as handing over the goods without asserting lien rights. A valid lien requires no prior waiver or inconsistent agreement.
- Lien Must Be Legally Recognised
Not everyone can claim a lien. It must be allowed either by statute or contract. For example, under Section 171 of the Indian Contract Act, only certain professionals like bankers, factors, wharfingers, attorneys, and policy brokers can exercise a general lien. Others may only claim a particular lien. Therefore, the lienholder must fall under a recognized category, or there must be a valid agreement allowing lien to be exercised legally.
- Services Rendered Must Be Related to Goods
In the case of a particular lien, the services provided must relate directly to the goods retained. For instance, a jeweler who polishes a necklace can hold it until payment is made, but cannot retain a ring for charges on the necklace. The debt and the goods must be connected, ensuring fairness. This essential condition restricts the use of lien to goods specifically associated with the unpaid service or cost.
- Lien is a Passive Right
Valid lien is a passive right to retain, not an active right to sell or profit from the goods. The lienholder can only hold the goods, not use or dispose of them, unless otherwise provided by contract or law. If the goods are sold or misused, the lienholder may be held liable for conversion or breach of trust. This essential feature protects the interests of the original owner and maintains legal accountability.
Types of Lien under Indian Law:
(As per the Indian Contract Act, 1872 – Sections 170 & 171)
A lien is the right to retain possession of goods belonging to another person until a lawful claim or payment is satisfied. Under Indian law, liens are broadly categorized into two main types:
1. Particular Lien (Section 170)
Particular lien gives a person the right to retain only those specific goods for which charges or dues have arisen. It is applicable when someone has rendered a service involving labour or skill over specific goods and is unpaid for it.
Essentials:
-
-
Must involve improvement or service of goods.
-
Bailee must have lawful possession.
-
No agreement contrary to lien.
-
Example: A mechanic who repairs a car may retain that specific car until the repair bill is paid.
Professionals entitled: Any person who has worked upon goods, like cobblers, tailors, mechanics, etc.
2. General Lien (Section 171)
General lien allows certain professio nals to retain any goods or securities in their possession for a general balance of account, even if the debts do not relate to the specific goods held.
Applicable to:
-
-
Bankers
-
Factors
-
Wharfingers
-
Attorneys of High Court
-
Policy-brokers
-
Essentials:
-
-
Legal recognition under Section 171.
-
Goods must be lawfully possessed.
-
A general account must be due and unsettled.
-
Example: A bank can hold all securities and documents deposited by a customer until their total outstanding loan is repaid.
Note: This lien can be excluded or modified by contract between the parties.
